Is an Open Concept Floor Plan the Best Choice? Maybe, Maybe Not...

The idea of an open-concept living space started growing in popularity after the end of the Second World War when growing American families desired a more open home that made it easier to keep an eye on young children. Modern advances in steel beam construction also made it possible to create larger, open rooms without difficulty. 

While there are situations where an open concept living space might be an ideal choice, I don't think every home or family should automatically assume it is the best floorplan option. In today's post, I am going over three potential problems with an open concept plan and how you can best avoid these downsides while creating a space that feels open!

Problem 1: Generally Lacking in Privacy

With fewer walls in a floor plan, the ability to have privacy is significantly reduced. Noise will travel, and unsightly messes will become harder to hide from guests. I recommend having a closed kitchen but an open dining/living space to avoid some of these downsides.  A small, enclosed study is a great place to find quiet solitude when desired. 

So rather than having a completely open concept floorplan or one with multiple small rooms, create a balance of both so you can achieve a greater feeling of openness without sacrificing the benefits of walls.

Problem 2: Short & Long Term Expenses

If you want to renovate an existing home, tearing out walls can be a simple process or a structural nightmare. Consulting with a structural engineer before making changes prevents possible costly issues down the road. Another potentially expensive aspect of an open concept floor plan is heat and cool costs. A home with separate spaces and an HVAC zoning system allows you to maintain the ideal temperature in the most used spaces without keeping the entire floor at the same temperature. This flexibility can mean using less energy without sacrificing comfort.

Problem 3: Cohesion is More Difficult to Maintain

From an interior design standpoint, an open concept floorplan creates certain obstacles not found in a traditional layout. For one, wall finishes and flooring are much more challenging to transition. There is also a lot more pressure to keep a design scheme on point throughout the entire space, particularly when it comes to colors and mood. Creating different design effects, such as an accent ceiling color, is much easier when you have a home with defined spaces.

When it comes to having an open concept floor plan, there is no right or wrong answer. Both have pros and cons, and each home might lend better to one or the other. If your home feels small and cramped, removing one or two walls might be the best solution to creating a greater sense of space without expanding. 

Which is the best solution for your home? That's what we’re here for! :)

If you're ready to make that interior design hire, reach out to us. We can't wait to hear about the floor plan you're dreaming of.

Until next time,

Donna